Galway City Tribune - Opinion Piece

Galway has opportunity to help 'Turn off the Red Light'

July 19, 2012 - 10:52am
By Denise Charlton, CEO of the Immigrant Council of Ireland

After years of campaigning, the opportunity has finally arrived to put people smugglers, pimps and criminals operating a sex trade in Galway and communities in the West of Ireland out of business.

The Dáil Committee on Justice is now inviting people and groups to make submissions on our prostitution laws with a deadline of August 31. We hope groups, individuals and politicians from Galway will join us in seeking new laws.

These short few weeks represent the first real opportunity in years to bring about change and if we let it slip by it may not re-occur for decades.

We believe the core issue is to close a loophole in the law which allows payment for sex. It is a legal oversight which will come as a surprise to many people who may have believed that prostitution in all its forms is illegal in Ireland.

This loophole has allowed a sordid industry to flourish with those responsible trafficking women into almost every town in Ireland to force them to work in an ‘industry’ where threats, violence and abuse are an everyday occurrence. Often big events such as the Galway Races are targeted with women forced to work in the shadows of the festivities.

A quick trawl of the Internet, as well as the actions of the Gardaí, show brothels are operating in Galway. In addition official figures confirm that two-thirds of people trafficked say they were brought to Ireland to work in the sex industry.

Last year 57 trafficking victims were identified, of which seven were children, brought here to be sexually abused.

At the Immigrant Council we have joined more than 50 partners to call for an end to this abuse of human rights under the banner ‘Turn off the Red Light’. In Galway we have the support of members of Macra Na Feirme, the Irish Country Women’s Association as well as members of leading trade unions and the ICTU.

Our campaign has looked at the experience in other European countries and met with police chiefs, policy makers and victim’s groups right across the EU. Almost unanimously all agree that prosecuting those who buy sex is the only way to end the misery for their victims.

For more, read this week's Galway City Tribune.

Contributor: 

Latest Opinion Pieces

Comments

The "Turn Off The Red Light" campaign is not telling the truth about the real reality of the sex trade in Ireland. They are only putting forth a biased one sided view and campaign that excludes the opinions and advice of active sex workers and sex worker rights organisations that disagree with any proposals of criminalising sex workers clients.

The majority of brothel offenses in Ireland are of consenting fully adult sex workers being criminalised for operating in two's and three's for safety reasons.

Prostitution has been fully legalised and regulated in a lot of european countries, there is obviously a large amount of people that choose to sell sexual services voluntarily, at the very least they should have the same basic human rights as other consenting sexually active adults have.

By attempting to criminalise sex workers by portraying them as victims and their clients as criminals, then it only creates more problems for sex workers, who would be forced into underground circumstances where the potential for danger drastically increases as seen in Sweden, Norway and Iceland.

An important UN report advises against criminalising sex workers clients, yet the "Turn Off The Red Light" campaign shuns that report.

The main organisation calling for criminalisation of sex workers services, is the Ruhama NGO, whose founders and trustees were the same congregations that ran the magdalene laundries in Ireland where the women held in them are seen as victims of abuse.

The issue of prostitution must be looked at in an objective manner. Radical feminists and Nuns from Ruhama should not be seen as the spokespeople for sex workers who completely disagree with their outrageous proposals.